Posted By : Chris Taylor,
07-Jul-2005, 03:08pm
In general terms, your gearbox is about the same beneath the selector casing as a 3 rail 4 synchro Spitfire gearbox. The basic design is the
same, but the ratios are different and any parts should be bought as Spitfire 1500 (or Dolomite 1500 etc).
Hence, once the top cover is off, dismantling etc is the same as for earlier Spitfire. (However, although again similar and a direct
descendant, this is NOT the same as a Herald or Spit 1-3 gearbox. Big difference is synchronised first gear).
If it's at all like the earlier gearbox, I think the problem being described to you is breakage of the circlip that holds the complete
gearcluster to the mainshaft.This is at the FRONT end of the mainshaft and does not require removal of any of the mainshaft components. That's
the good news!
BUT, to get at it properly, you need to remove the overdrive (so you can tilt the mainshaft up and remove it from the gearbox). Also, remove
the layshaft and drop laygear into the bottom of the box. While it can remain there, unfortunately it's highly likely that all the needle
rollers will fall out when you remove the layshaft so you would not be able to reassemble unless you can arrange a short dummy shaft to retain
them in position.
Also remove the input shaft (forwards). Then you can see the front of the mainshaft and hopefully the suspect circlip. To deal with it properly
you need to drive the mainshaft forwards out of the gearbox housing and deal with on the bench.
This then begs the question of, having come this far, what else do you replace. Changing the main bearings (and DEFINITELY the roller bearing
inside the input shaft, in which the tip of the mainshaft locates) requires little further dismantling, but that still leaves layshaft roller
bearings, layshaft thrust washers, and the synchro rings, all of which wear).
If you are really unlucky, the mainshaft tip can snap off and cause such 3rd gear problems, although that is much more of a problem on earlier
gearboxes and D type overdrives, especially if the shaft has been "retipped". This might also result in more overall noise in ALL the indirect
gears but normal (relative!) silence in 4th.
It IS also possible that sudden difficulty in engaging 3rd gear could be breakage of the springs within the 3rd/4th gear synchro hub, but that
would probably also affect 4th gear to an extent and does not really explain difficulty in DISengaging 3rd.
All this IS DIYable and most manuals are quite good about the processes, but can be quite involved which is why a lot of people opt for an
exchange gearbox.
While it is out of the car it might at least be worth taking the top off and seeing if there is anything obviously wrong with the 3rd/4th gear
synchro hub which might account for binding etc.
If, with 3rd gear engaged (synchro hub moved backwards) there is signs of the mainshaft being able to be moved sideways (or upwards) in
relation to the input shaft, that might hint at a broken mainshaft tip. However you would be surprised that the input and main shafts do have
SOME movement anyway.
If, with 3rd gear engaged, it seems that you can move the 3rd gear itself forwards by more than a few thou, then the circlip may be broken.
(However, the gear will be held by its engagement with the layhsaft gear so things may not be too obvious!)
-
Posted By : Charles Lowe,
12-Jul-2005, 11:13pm
Well it was the third gear circlip that had broken in the end, it was in three pieces! Unfortunately i didn't use a correct size dummy
layshaft and the needles fell out, so i've taken apart the gearbox completely now, and i've bought various circlips and a reverse idler
gear that was looking pretty worn, and i'm going to attempt to put everything back in the right place and get it back in the car.
Looking at the moss catalogue it has three tension springs between the thrust washer and the bellhousing in the exploded diagram, as i
don't think these were in the gear box when i took it out, but there does appear to be three holes for them so should i put some new ones
in?
Charlie
-
Posted By : Chris Taylor,
15-Jul-2005, 03:14pm
Oh dear, I bet you had a rather sinking feeling when you found the layshaft would not go back in properly, and another one when you
realised what you were going to have to do to put it right!
Now the gearbox is in bits, you should seriously consider doing a more major overhaul. The bits are not too expensive, but the labour
of taking it all apart and reassembling is, so now is an obvious time to do this unless you know the rest of the box is fine and the
circlip was the only problem. (Any indications why it broke?)
I would definitely replace the needle roller bearing inside the input shaft. I would almost certainly replace the two main ball races
for the input shaft and mainshaft. I would also replace all the layshaft rollers.
Measure the layshaft end float. If it is over spec, see if you can get new thrust washers. FITTING THE SPRINGS will not change the
endfloat, they just stop any chatter at idle by holding the thrust washer against the laygears. It is quite feasible to run without
them. Although Vitesse's had them, related Herald boxes did not, so they do not seem to be essential. If they are readily available and
cheap, I'd probably fit them, but I'm not really sure why I say that!!!!!
The big "do I don't I" question nowadays is whether to change the synchro rings. If you have a decent manual, you can get an idea of
how worn they are (you also need to see whether the internal ribbing is worn down). While they are easy enough to change while the box
is in bits, I'm told that the quality of riungs available these days is not good or at least patchy, and so you might be wasting your
money.